PAUL, KAUSHIK (2021) Behind the Veil: The Quest for Personal Autonomy. Doctoral thesis, Durham University.
|Full text not available from this repository.|
Author-imposed embargo until 24 January 2024.
Islamic veiling has attracted a remarkable degree of international and domestic attention in the current political climate. While an increasing number of countries have enacted legislation to prohibit Muslim women from wearing Islamic veils, in some countries Muslim women are coerced into wearing traditional religious dress. Forced veiling is a crucial human rights issue, yet it has not been fully explored in existing legal literature. This study analyses forced unveiling and forced veiling, two completely different stories, simultaneously and with equal importance by centring on the concept of ‘personal autonomy’. It examines the implications of forced veiling on Muslim women’s right to respect for private life and right to freedom of religion.
In the popular and political debates, three justifications are commonly invoked to justify bans on Islamic veils: social cohesion; public safety and security; and, gender equality. Through the viewpoint of John Stuart Mill’s harm principle, this research examines whether a State can legitimately regulate the wearing of Islamic veils on these grounds. This is therefore unique research as it is the first study of this kind and thus, demonstrates an original contribution to knowledge.
This study explores and critically analyses the divergent approaches the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the ECtHR”) and the United Nations (hereinafter “the UN”) have taken concerning legal bans on Islamic veils. The comparative study reveals that the ECtHR has given weak protection to the religious freedom of Muslim women who want to manifest their religion through the wearing of Islamic veils. Therefore, this thesis offers a systematic analysis as to what lessons the ECtHR can take from the UN to give effective protection to Muslim women’s religious freedom, and how the ECtHR can strengthen its proportionality analysis to determine whether a legal ban on wearing the Islamic veil is justified.
|Item Type:||Thesis (Doctoral)|
|Award:||Doctor of Philosophy|
|Faculty and Department:||Faculty of Social Sciences and Health > Law, Department of|
|Copyright:||Copyright of this thesis is held by the author|
|Deposited On:||25 Jan 2021 12:26|